Monday, 18 May 2015

Asking people to help pay for the pool is outrageous

I recently received a letter from the Shire's Bridgetown-Greenbushes Pool Fundraising Project.

They asked me to "contribute to this community project."

It is not a community project, it is a Shire Council project. The letter lacked detail as to how any contributed funds would be spent.

I replied, declining the request and gave the following reasons;

1. You have not properly explained what funds raised will be used for. "Some of the costs" and "additional pool equipment" are very vague descriptions. I would like to know how much of the costs are yet to be covered by ratepayers funds and borrowings. I would also like to know what equipment is not covered by the tender awarded to construct a pool and associated infrastructure.

2. I do not understand why a public fundraising drive is required to help pay for an upgrade to Council property. Surely this project falls within the Capital Works Program and Budget of the Council and hence should be properly funded as part of the Council's operations.

3. You appear to be double dipping. (We) already pay annual rates to the shire, which we expect will be used among other things to fund the provision of public amenities.

4. I think the project has been poorly managed. I do not understand why the existing pool was demolished a year ago, when all that has been done since then is to dig a hole in the ground.

5. If the Council had taken a pragmatic and prudent approach, it would have simply fixed whatever real problems (leaving aside aesthetic issues) there were with the existing pool, rather than demolishing it and starting again. This would have been a much less expensive and time-consuming option, thereby removing the need for public fundraising.

Sunday, 12 April 2015

Tree, what tree?

I understand Shire CEO Tim Clynch has been busy hosing down the issues raised by a former Council employee ..... outlined in previous posts here.

Mr Clynch and the councillors have had a nice little chat about it all behind closed doors and the upshot is that its just a storm in a teacup, everything has been fully investigated and nobody has done anything wrong.

Included in his briefing was a statement that some of my information was wrong. It was not the case that a native tree was felled (without a clearing permit) for timber to build the fancy outdoor recreational facility for staff.

Well, what do we have here?

That's a recently chopped down tree in the depot grounds.

And what's this?

This is what's left of the tree after it had been cut into lengths of timber at the back of the depot with a Lucas Mill belonging to a Shire staff member.

And finally...


There's the timber being used to make the patio.

I've asked the councillors if they think there is anything wrong with any of this and they have simply circled the wagons, claiming they are not allowed to pursue the issues because they are "operational". They have been trained to see their role as nothing more than rubber stamps for decisions made by the senior staff.

The councillors are ignoring  their responsibility to make sure the CEO is doing his job properly.  And if these sorts of things are going on and senior staff including the CEO are simply covering up, that is surely a matter for councillors.

For instance, if the CEO says he has investigated something, but he has never interviewed the complainant, is that a satisfactory investigation???


Tuesday, 7 April 2015

It's called turning a blind eye



After being informed about the issues raised in the post below this one, I went along to the Council  Meeting on Thursday 26 of March and used public question time to ask the President, Mr Pratico what he did when a Shire employee informed him late last year that illegal activities were taking place at the Shire depot.  This is a transcript of his answers, and some given by the CEO, Mr Clynch. The answers  surprised me.  They might surprise you too. 


My questions to the President   re; former Shire employee Kevin Edsall

11.    In late November last year, when then Shire employee Kevin Edsall, who was the fleet manager at the depot, approached you at the Agricultural Show and reported the theft of steel beams from the Shire Depot by a fellow employee, what action did you take?
President: “When that was reported to me, the matter had already been reported to the CEO previous to that, so I made the CEO aware of the theft.”
My follow up: Do you know…what was the outcome?
 “The CEO  attended to it and the material was returned.”


22.    When Mr Edsall reported to you that his colleagues at the depot had cut down a jarrah tree on crown land and were using Shire supplies and equipment in work hours to construct a recreational amenity, that is an enclosed deck, for themselves on Shire property at the depot, what action did you take?
President: “I think that the Manager of Works was aware that enclosure being built, so there was no action for me to take.”
My follow up: Do you know whether a building permit was sought or obtained for the structure which was built?
Answer from CEO: “No, my understanding is that a building permit was not required for that work."
Why was that?
CEO: “I just made the inquiry and that was the response I got.”


33.    When Mr Edsall later reported to you that not long after him raising the previously mentioned issues, one of his colleagues at the depot had presented him with a spent .22 calibre bullet shell at his workplace, what action did you take?
President: “He… when I questioned why he was presented with that, his response was the Shire employee who presented it said he found it.”
Follow up: Did you not see that as a case of bullying or intimidation in the workplace?
President:  “As Shire President, if it was a case of bullying, or if Mr Edsall felt it was bullying, he should have gone to his superior in the workplace, which was the Manager of Works."
I believe he did report it, but what was your reaction?
"I do not believe it is the Shire President’s role to interfere in operational matters.”
Answer from CEO: "I conducted an investigation into that matter and arrived at a conclusion that there was no…"
What was your finding?
"I decided there was no case of bullying in that situation."

Thursday, 26 March 2015

One set of rules for Council staff (none), and another set of rules for the rest of us mugs

Some time last year, the boys up at the Shire depot decided the confines of their lunch room were a little too restricted, so they cut a hole in the wall, chopped down a nearby jarrah tree and went to work cutting it up (mostly during work hours) and building themselves a patio entertainment area.

Apparently its a fabulous place to enjoy all the free beers donated to the work crews by grateful members of the community who get their roads graded regularly or their verges cleared.

A few small problems with this, though...

1. It is illegal to chop down trees without a clearing permit
2. It is  illegal to erect a structure like this without a building permit
3. It is highly inappropriate to use Council-owned equipment and materials during work hours for an unbudgeted expense like this.
4. It is unethical for public servants to accept free cartons of beer for doing their job.

You would expect someone like Shire President Tony Pratico to be aware of the points outlined above and to take strong action if he was informed about something like this, but sadly, you would be wrong.

At last night's Council meeting I asked him what he did when he was told about the situation by a worker at the depot who didn't like what was going on.

The President's reply: "The Manager of Works told me he was aware of that being built, so I took no action."

I then asked whether a building permit had been sought or obtained for the structure.

Council CEO Tim Clynch replied: "I was told no building permit was required."

Wait a minute...  He was told?  As the CEO and a former town planner, surely he knows the rules regarding building permits?

So if you and I, fellow citizens and ratepayers, wanted to cut down a native tree for some timber, we'd need a permit and if we wished to extend our dwellings and build patios, we'd need a permit.

But in the Shire of Bridgetown-Greenbushes, if you are council employees the rules apparently do not apply.


Thursday, 19 March 2015

Employment conditions are secret, apparently

I recently rang the Council and asked to see a copy of its Collective Employee Agreement.

Many other WA Councils make their employment agreements available on the via their websites. Not ours -- far from it -- as you will see from this email exchange:



From: Tim Clynch [mailto:tClynch@bridgetown.wa.gov.au]
Sent: Wednesday, 11 March 2015 2:26 PM
To: Michael Southwell (southy@iinet.net.au)
Subject: Request for Information

Hi Michael

Emily from the front counter has referred to me your request for a copy of the Shire’s collective employee agreement.

Please note the Shire currently has a collective employee agreement for the outside works staff and an enterprise bargaining agreement for inside staff. 

With regard to your request for copies of either one or both of these agreements I have referred to Section 5.94 of the Local Government Act. 

An employee collective agreement is not a document defined under Section 5.94 as being available for inspection by the public.  Therefore there is no automatic right to access that information.

Both agreements were considered by Council at its June 2013 meeting as confidential items “behind closed doors”.  Therefore the contents of each Agreement are considered confidential and are not available for inspection by members of the public.

Based on the above I am not able to provide you with a copy of either one or both of the agreements.

If you are dissatisfied with my decision you are able to request consideration under Freedom of Information legislation.  Application forms can be obtained from the Shire’s Records officer Eileen Kneale.  Under the FOI legislation if your FOI application is declined by the Shire appeal rights would be available to you.

Regards
Tim Clynch
Chief Executive Officer

Shire of Bridgetown-Greenbushes






From: Michael Southwell [mailto:southy@iinet.net.au]
Sent: Thursday, 12 March 2015 11:09 AM
To: Tim Clynch
Subject: RE: Request for Information

Hi Tim,

In arriving at your decision to keep this document secret, did you consider Council’s stated Values, which include being “open and accountable”?

The fact that the document was considered as a confidential item at Council does not support your argument that it is secret, given that the decision to consider it behind closed doors would have occurred at your suggestion.

Similar documents are publicly available at other Councils.  Perhaps you should check with the Department on whether the document should be publicly available, as you have on other issues.

I should not be made to go through the time and expense of an FOI request, when there is no good reason to keep the document secret.

Regards,

Michael

Hi Michael

Once an item is accepted by Council as confidential under Council’s Standing Orders I am not permitted to release the information to the public.

Section 5.94 of the Local Government Act lists the local government information available for public inspection.  An employee collective agreement or similar is not identified as a document freely available for inspection.

Prior to making my decision I did consult with the Department of Local Government and Communities and their advice was that the document was not of a type that would normally be freely available to the public but at the end of the day the decision to release it rested with the CEO.  As stated previously, as the matter was considered by Council behind closed doors I am not authorised to release it for public inspection.

The Local Government Act identifies the types of matters that can be considered by a council behind closed doors, one of which is “a matter affecting an employee or employees”.  An employee collective agreement or EBA is such a document.

I am happy to stand by Council’s values of being open and accountable but I also am obliged to work within the requirements of the Local Government Act, other legislation, Shire of Bridgetown-Greenbushes Local laws and Council Policies.

Regards

Tim Clynch
Chief Executive Officer

Shire of Bridgetown-Greenbushes

 

 
So  some of the people in Bridgetown (councillors, council employees, and presumably their families) are allowed to have this information about  employment conditions at the Shire and others (ratepayers) are not.

I must go to the time, trouble and expense of an FOI request to see this innocuous document.

I will be entitled to the document under FOI, and unless Mr Clynch is completely ignorant about the FOI Act, he knows that. 

The only material exempt under the Act is that which reveals personal information, might harm the State's economic interests, is commercially confidential, is protected by legal privilege, may interfere with law enforcement or jeopardise national security.

The CEO is simply playing a game.  The object of the game is to discourage people from scrutinising Council activities.